An eight-year content writer posted in r/SEO this summer about a day spent cranking out pages titled "GMC dealer in [city]" and "Jeep dealer in [city]," with more of the same promised for tomorrow. They called it work they'd never put in a portfolio, and 83 comments piled on in sympathy.
SEO writing is going to be the death of me
I’ve been a content writer for 8 years and SEO writing has never been my favorite part of the job, but I’m good and it. And obviously, it comes with the territory. But good god, I can’t do it anymore. Today I have written pages titled • GMC...
That's SEO copywriting as an unexplained pile of rules. This checklist runs 12 checks on one page right before it goes live, and each one carries a dated source, so you know why it's there. Sources were checked on October 19, 2026.
When I searched this exact phrase in October, Google put its own AI Overview first. Not one page ranking underneath it cited a source for its own advice.
The SEO copywriting checklist at a glance
Run it top to bottom, one page at a time. Each section below walks through a single check.
| # | Check | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Title tag and H1 promise the same page | Google title links doc, December 2025 |
| 2 | The answer sits in the first 100 words | Kevin Indig via Search Engine Land, February 2026 |
| 3 | Headings are the reader's questions | Indig study, plus Google's SEO Starter Guide |
| 4 | Key sentences make sense on their own | Indig study |
| 5 | Every number has a named source and a year | GEO paper, KDD 2024 |
| 6 | Words are short and blocks are easy to scan | Nielsen Norman Group, 1997 and 2020 |
| 7 | A byline and a date are visible | Google helpful content guidance, October 2026 |
| 8 | Internal links use anchors that name the page | Google title links doc |
| 9 | The meta description fits this page only | Google snippet doc, April 2026, and Ahrefs, 2020 |
| 10 | The FAQ answers real questions briefly | University of Toronto, October 2026 |
| 11 | Every image has alt text | Google SEO Starter Guide, December 2025 |
| 12 | The CTA is one plain next step | Nielsen Norman Group, 1997 |
If the page isn't drafted yet, start with our blog post outline template first. This list covers the copy itself.
1. Make the title tag and H1 agree
Google builds the blue link from several inputs, and your title tag is just one. Its title links documentation, updated December 10, 2025, says that link can come from the <title> element, the main heading, other prominent page text, or the anchor text of links pointing at it. Missing, stale, vague or mismatched title tags all give Google a reason to write its own.
Read the title tag and H1 side by side and check they promise the same page, with the main keyword near the front of both.
2. Put the answer in the first 100 words
Growth advisor Kevin Indig studied 1.2 million AI answers and 18,012 verified citations. As Search Engine Land reported on February 18, 2026, 44.2% of the ChatGPT citations in his data traced to the first 30% of a page, with just under a quarter from the last third.
Ask whether someone reading only your first paragraph walks away with the answer. If your intro sets the scene for three paragraphs first, cut it to two sentences. Our guide to structuring content for ChatGPT covers that engine's own quirks.
3. Write headings as the reader's questions
The same dataset found something about headings too. Cited passages ran roughly twice as likely to be tied to a question, and 78.4% of those question-linked citations came straight from headings. Indig's read is that ChatGPT treats an H2 something like a prompt.
How many headings does a page need? Google's SEO Starter Guide, updated the same day as the title links page, won't give a number. It says heading order doesn't move rankings, and a page that feels like it has too many probably does. Write each H2 as a question someone would type, or phrase it the way they'd say it out loud.
4. Write sentences that still work when quoted alone
An AI answer typically lifts a sentence or two and drops the rest. Indig found cited passages ran about twice as likely to use plain, definite phrasing like "X is" or "X means." They were also packed with names, proper nouns making up 20.6% of that text against just 5% to 8% in ordinary writing.
Paste your three most important sentences into a blank doc, one at a time. If any say "it" or "this tool" with no clear antecedent, put the real name back in. If the page needs a short summary block near the top, our post on the key takeaways tactic has a ready template.
5. Give every number a name and a year
Call this the receipt rule. Every number on a page needs a receipt attached, meaning who found it and when. "Studies show most buyers research online" has no receipt at all, while "Nielsen Norman Group found in 1997" has one, and the year shows at a glance how fresh it is.
The GEO paper by Aggarwal and colleagues, presented at KDD 2024, found that adding citations, quotes and statistics could lift a source's visibility in AI answers by up to 40%. That came from a lab test on a research engine, and the gain swung wildly by topic, so nobody can promise you that exact lift on your own pages.
6. Use short words and blocks people can scan
People still scan rather than read. Back in 1997, Nielsen Norman Group found that 79% of test users scanned any new page, with only 16% reading word by word. Its 2020 follow-up pulled together 13 years of eye-tracking across more than 500 people and found scanning still dominant.
AI engines seem to prefer plain writing too. In Indig's data, cited passages read at roughly a grade 16 level, against 19.1 for passages that performed worse. Break up long paragraphs, swap long words for short ones, and turn comparisons into a table instead of a sentence.

You're getting AI traffic. But do you know where it comes from?
RankControl credits every visit to the assistant that sent it: ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude, Gemini, Copilot, or Grok. Full source attribution, next to your Google traffic.
7. Show who wrote it and when
Google's helpful content guidance, updated October 5, 2026, asks you to write for people first. It also wants clear sourcing, a named author, and openness about any AI or automation used. A byline reading "admin" falls short, and so does a page with no visible date.
Put a real name and a visible date on the page, and only change that date if the content actually, meaningfully changed.
8. Check internal links and their anchor text
Google reads the anchor text of links pointing at a page when deciding that page's own title link, and your internal links are anchors you directly control. "Click here" tells Google nothing about whatever sits on the other end.
Add two to four links to genuinely related pages, each carrying an anchor that names its destination. Our post on internal link structure covers planning that across a whole site.
9. Write a meta description for this page only
A thread in r/TechSEO asked whether meta descriptions are pointless, and the top reply said Google just rewrites the bad ones anyway. Ahrefs put a number on that in a 2020 study, finding Google rewrote them 62.78% of the time.
That study is six years old now, and newer, smaller reports put the real rate higher. Google's own snippet documentation, updated April 20, 2026, explains why: it may pull different page text instead, whenever that describes the page better than your written description does. Write one for every page anyway, as a specific summary rather than a string of keywords.
Match it to the page's main query too. Rewrites ran more common on long-tail searches (65.62%) than on short, broad ones (59.65%).
We'll show you exactly where your brand stands in AI search.
No commitment. $0 due today, cancel anytime. See how ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude, Gemini, Grok, Google AI Mode, and Google AI Overviews talk about your brand today.

The last three checks
These three take a few minutes each.
10. Keep the FAQ short and real
Pull FAQ questions from People Also Ask, sales calls, support tickets and forum threads, then answer each in two or three sentences drawn from the page's own content. Don't bolt on an FAQ just because a checklist told you to. The Toronto study in the next section found FAQ blocks and schema looked useful mainly comparing different websites, far less so comparing pages on the same site.
11. Give every image alt text
The SEO Starter Guide asks for short alt text that explains what an image shows and how it relates to the page. "Image1" or "chart" fails outright. "Line chart of weekly signups falling from 400 to 250 in March" passes, putting the image's one real fact into text an engine can actually read.
12. End with one plain next step
The 1997 Nielsen work found that plain, objective wording scored 27% higher on usability than promotional wording did. A call to action that states exactly what happens after the click, "see the price list," "book a table for Friday", beats one that just shouts at the reader.
What copy can't do on its own
In October 2026, Mahe Chen and Nick Koudas at the University of Toronto published a study covering 158,099 AI answers and 468,037 citations over 90 days. Within a single website, page-level copy choices explained only about 2.8% of the difference in which pages got cited. The engine's own search step explained roughly 32%, well over ten times as much.
So copy is a small gate, not the whole door. It makes a page easy to quote once an engine has already pulled it in, but what the engine searched for decides which page gets pulled. The two studies measure different things too. Indig compared cited text against uncited text, which can't separate good copy from good retrieval, and the Toronto paper covers one 90-day window.
Being cited isn't the finish line either. In an r/SaaS thread about getting cited by ChatGPT, the top comment came from someone whose own article got cited, only to recommend a competitor.
Clicks bring their own headache. An SEO in r/SEO asked how to explain to clients that AI Overviews had cut their traffic, since the clients assumed "adding an FAQ section will fix everything." Several replies suggested splitting Search Console queries by whether an AI Overview shows for them.
How do you explain to clients that traffic dropped because of AI Overviews? Do they actually get it? Have you lost a client over it?
Most of my clients are B2B and used to get a lot of their leads from informational articles and queries. Now I can see AI Overviews answering most of those queries directly, so people just don't click anymore. The problem is that clients do...
That makes the work after publishing mostly a matter of watching. Rankings and citations shift week to week, and a page that passed every check in November can lose its spot by spring with no edit to blame. For older pages already live, our content optimization process helps decide which to fix first.
How long the checklist takes
As a rough estimate, running all 12 checks on a finished draft takes 20 to 30 minutes, and fixing whatever fails takes another 30 to 60. At eight new pages a month, that's 7 to 12 hours of editing, before any writing or tracking.
For a homepage or pricing page, what you say matters more than these mechanical checks, and our guide to website copywriting covers that side of it.
Doing it yourself or handing it off
RankControl's content engine writes each article against the pages already ranking for its keyword and publishes it on your own site. Auto-publish is off by default, so you review each one before it goes live. Our AI visibility tracking then checks your buyer questions every week across seven AI engines. There's one flat plan at $400 a month with a 7-day free trial. Expect Google traffic to move first, with citations following more slowly as other sites link to and mention you.
You can run this checklist by hand on every single page. Or RankControl can write, publish and check the pages every week while you decide what your company actually has to say.
Know exactly what AI says about your competitors.
RankControl's Recon Agent monitors competitor citations across ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude, Gemini, Grok, Google AI Mode, and Google AI Overviews. See where they show up and you don't.










